محبوبترین نویسندگان :
نویسندگان مقالات پربازدید :
مجموعه مقالات حقوق جزا و فلسفه 1392
جزئیات رویداد
اینستاگرام تی پی بین
همایش ، رویداد ، ژورنال
حوزه های تحت پوشش رویداد

  • in defense of “pure” legal moralism

    نویسندگان :
    کلمات کلیدی :
    جزئیات بیشتر مقاله
    • تاریخ ارائه: 1392/07/24
    • تاریخ انتشار در تی پی بین: 1392/07/24
    • تعداد بازدید: 944
    • تعداد پرسش و پاسخ ها: 0
    • شماره تماس دبیرخانه رویداد: -
     in this paper i argue that joel feinberg was wrong to suppose that liberals must oppose any criminalization of “harmless immorality”. the problem with a theory that permits criminalization only on the basis of his harm and offense principles is that it is underinclusive, ruling out laws that most liberals believe are justified. one objection (arthur ripstein’s) is that feinberg’s theory is unable to account for the criminalization of harmless personal grievances. another (larry alexander’s and robert george’s) is that it cannot account for public decency laws. i shall reject both of these underinclusiveness objections in favor of one that focuses on the “free floating evil” of corpse desecration. liberals need “pure” legal moralism (plm) to explain their support for a criminal ban on mistreatment of the dead. i also argue that while deterrence is plausibly regarded as the primary rationale for criminalizing and punishing wrongs like murder or rape, it is not plausibly regarded as any part of the rationale for criminalizing free floating evils. the point of punishing corpse desecrators has to be either retribution or the promotion of virtue/discouraging of vice. finally, i consider feinberg’s reason for rejecting all plm, namely, that competent adults have a right to personal sovereignty or autonomy, and the state’s duty to respect that right trumps the desirability of punishing or reducing the vice associated with harmless immorality. i argue that feinberg’s argument here fails because it exaggerates the right’s strength and scope.

سوال خود را در مورد این مقاله مطرح نمایید :

با انتخاب دکمه ثبت پرسش، موافقت خود را با قوانین انتشار محتوا در وبسایت تی پی بین اعلام می کنم
مقالات جدیدترین رویدادها
مقالات جدیدترین ژورنال ها